Voltage spikes and Sags with MS II V3.0
Posted: Thu Jun 16, 2011 9:57 am
Hi guys,
I'm having some major voltage spike and sag issues with MSII V3.0. I originally thought the issue was my tune until I started data logging. Upon closer inspection when the voltage spikes the car leans out immediately after, when the voltage sags the car goes rich. You feel the car shutter for a brief moment as well when this happens. This happens during all driving conditions as well as when im crusing at a steady rpm with constant light throttle. I was wondering if anyone has had any similar issues or if theres something else I can try for a fix.
For info on my car its a 1982 280zx Datsun and for Megasquirt im running MSII V3.0 with a relay board that a friend and I put together. I am also running version 2.6 of the firmware on Megasquirt. The battery has been mounted in the trunk of my car and I've got a thick (2-4 gauge) power wire running from the battery to the starter. The ground wire (2-4 gauge) for the battery is grounded to the trunk of the car. Originally the relay board was pulling power from the factory ECU wire, and was grounded to 3 spots. It was wired with aproximately 16-18 gauge wire for both power and ground. The switched power on the relay board is coming from a 16-18 gauge wire that powered the original ECU.
To try and remedy the problem of the voltage sags and spikes last night we re wired the relay board's power and ground wires with 12 gauge wire. The relay board now pulls power directly from the starter where the battery and alternator connect. The relay board also has one 12 gauge ground now that grounds on the starter where there is a thick (4-6 gauge) factory wire that grounds to the frame. The switched power (16-18 gauge) wire from the factory ecu is still in place. After re wiring the issue doesn't seem to have improved at all unfortunately...
I'm just wondering what I should try next?
I have read that the battery can act like a capacitor and that running power off that may help to reduce the highs and lows?
Would updating the firmware on the ECU help remedy anything?
Could the switched 12 wire be causing anything like this?
I've thought about running a ground wire from the battery up to the starter but we did some tests and were able to find little to no resistance between the battery ground and the starter so haven't done that as of yet.
Could something be acting up on my megasquirt or relay board that would be causing this? We double checked and made sure the power,ground and switched 12 connections are nice and tight on the relay board and that nothing is loose.
If something on the board could be causing the issue is there anything I can check to make sure its working well? The board was originally built by me and a friend a couple years ago. I should add that I had the luck of living next to an electrical engineer who looked over the MS board and relay after we put it together and touched up any solders that he thought looked weak.
I've included some screen shots of the voltage sags and spikes. I tried to upload the datalog but its too large if its if any help let me know and I'll see if I can make it smaller. You'll notice my AFR's follow the trend of the voltage spikes and sags when throttle is constant as is RPM. (im running an AEM wideband sensor as well).
I'm having some major voltage spike and sag issues with MSII V3.0. I originally thought the issue was my tune until I started data logging. Upon closer inspection when the voltage spikes the car leans out immediately after, when the voltage sags the car goes rich. You feel the car shutter for a brief moment as well when this happens. This happens during all driving conditions as well as when im crusing at a steady rpm with constant light throttle. I was wondering if anyone has had any similar issues or if theres something else I can try for a fix.
For info on my car its a 1982 280zx Datsun and for Megasquirt im running MSII V3.0 with a relay board that a friend and I put together. I am also running version 2.6 of the firmware on Megasquirt. The battery has been mounted in the trunk of my car and I've got a thick (2-4 gauge) power wire running from the battery to the starter. The ground wire (2-4 gauge) for the battery is grounded to the trunk of the car. Originally the relay board was pulling power from the factory ECU wire, and was grounded to 3 spots. It was wired with aproximately 16-18 gauge wire for both power and ground. The switched power on the relay board is coming from a 16-18 gauge wire that powered the original ECU.
To try and remedy the problem of the voltage sags and spikes last night we re wired the relay board's power and ground wires with 12 gauge wire. The relay board now pulls power directly from the starter where the battery and alternator connect. The relay board also has one 12 gauge ground now that grounds on the starter where there is a thick (4-6 gauge) factory wire that grounds to the frame. The switched power (16-18 gauge) wire from the factory ecu is still in place. After re wiring the issue doesn't seem to have improved at all unfortunately...
I'm just wondering what I should try next?
I have read that the battery can act like a capacitor and that running power off that may help to reduce the highs and lows?
Would updating the firmware on the ECU help remedy anything?
Could the switched 12 wire be causing anything like this?
I've thought about running a ground wire from the battery up to the starter but we did some tests and were able to find little to no resistance between the battery ground and the starter so haven't done that as of yet.
Could something be acting up on my megasquirt or relay board that would be causing this? We double checked and made sure the power,ground and switched 12 connections are nice and tight on the relay board and that nothing is loose.
If something on the board could be causing the issue is there anything I can check to make sure its working well? The board was originally built by me and a friend a couple years ago. I should add that I had the luck of living next to an electrical engineer who looked over the MS board and relay after we put it together and touched up any solders that he thought looked weak.
I've included some screen shots of the voltage sags and spikes. I tried to upload the datalog but its too large if its if any help let me know and I'll see if I can make it smaller. You'll notice my AFR's follow the trend of the voltage spikes and sags when throttle is constant as is RPM. (im running an AEM wideband sensor as well).