Page 1 of 1
Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2017 12:34 pm
by fordfanboi
So I've had this fairly rare issue where I'll be driving along and the car will die for a few seconds.... then wake back up. I finally had it happen while logging and I noticed the RPM drops to 0 and the RUN field shown in MegaLog Viewer shows N. What determines when RUN will show N - or is that coming straight from the MSII serialization?
The MSII has power since the log acts normal other than 0 RPM. Could I be losing power to my Distributor (Mallory Unilite) or Ignition box (Mallory HyFire IVc) briefly or would something else cause RUN = N?
TY!
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2017 3:23 pm
by fordfanboi
Looks like the Engine serial protocol entry is likely what Run: is based on. Still not sure what would determine the value of Engine or what the different values represent.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Fri Mar 31, 2017 9:10 am
by fordfanboi
I have the original ballast resistor wire installed on my 1966 Ford Mustang which supplies power to the distributor and ignition box. It's not necessary so I'll try removing it and supplying a full 12v and see if that legacy item is the issue. Maybe it was dropping the power lower than is acceptable.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Mon Apr 03, 2017 8:27 am
by fordfanboi
Removed the ballast resistor wire and ran a dedicated power line to the dizzy and so far so good. Min value on Engine was 1 on my first 20+ minute trip. Will comment here if the problem comes back.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Tue Apr 04, 2017 4:24 am
by trakkies
Is MS working in a fuel only mode? Ie, not controlling the ignition timing? Whatever, if MS loses the tach signal it stops injecting as it thinks the engine has stopped.
Sadly, this could be a problem with your ignition system or MS
I used a Unilite with resistor for several years on fuel only MS. Mallory said to use the resistor, so I did.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Tue Apr 04, 2017 5:35 am
by fordfanboi
trakkies wrote:Is MS working in a fuel only mode? Ie, not controlling the ignition timing? Whatever, if MS loses the tach signal it stops injecting as it thinks the engine has stopped.
Sadly, this could be a problem with your ignition system or MS
I used a Unilite with resistor for several years on fuel only MS. Mallory said to use the resistor, so I did.
MS runs it all. The ignition box controls the coil, so no need for the ballast resistor (since IIRC it originally connected to the coil). The ignition signal that was going in to the ms2 (I think pin 24) was coming from the unilite, then the timing adjusted output went to the ignition box.
I believe that signal from the unilite was dead due to the resistor wire getting too hot and dropping voltage too low. A few seconds later maybe it cooled enough since there was no load and the unilite woke back up? Maybe? That's my guess anyhow.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Tue Apr 04, 2017 6:21 am
by trakkies
If the resistor was designed to handle the power the coil took when driven direct from the Unilite - single coil setup - it would carry virtually no current when feeding just the dizzy alone, with no coil. So would likely be doing nothing, so wouldn't get hot. Your ignition box would be taking the power now.
How are you deriving the tach signal from the Mallory setup, and what input are you using with MS?
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Tue Apr 04, 2017 9:26 am
by fordfanboi
trakkies wrote:If the resistor was designed to handle the power the coil took when driven direct from the Unilite - single coil setup - it would carry virtually no current when feeding just the dizzy alone, with no coil. So would likely be doing nothing, so wouldn't get hot. Your ignition box would be taking the power now.
How are you deriving the tach signal from the Mallory setup, and what input are you using with MS?
The Mallory IVc ignition box does share a power line with the Unilite, so in some part the resistor wire was supplying power to both the distributor and ignition box.
The Unilite only has 3 wires. Power, Ground, and Signal. That Signal goes to pin 24 (IIRC) on the MS2. It's had this setup since 2005 - just with intermittent power drop issues appearing more frequent over the last few years. Only recently did I manage to trap it in the log and found that the Engine field was dropping to 0. Who knows how old that resistor wire was too.
60 minutes driven since the change and zero Run:N entries in the logs. I'll call it fixed if I can make it a week of commute without an error.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Wed Apr 05, 2017 1:22 am
by trakkies
The resistor is there to help limit the maximum current your ignition setup can take. With the Unilite only setup I had, Mallory said it should be used - but oddly didn't supply it with the dizzy kit. You might be OK without, but I wouldn't be sure of that. It was very expensive for what it was, though.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Wed Apr 05, 2017 5:38 am
by fordfanboi
trakkies wrote:The resistor is there to help limit the maximum current your ignition setup can take. With the Unilite only setup I had, Mallory said it should be used - but oddly didn't supply it with the dizzy kit. You might be OK without, but I wouldn't be sure of that. It was very expensive for what it was, though.
Yes, it could eventually wipe it out. If this is the fix, I'll purchase the Mallory ballast resistor they sell separately. If it's not the fix, the old wire goes back in haha
https://m.summitracing.com/parts/msd-8214
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Wed Apr 05, 2017 6:22 am
by fordfanboi
That was the msd part no. Mallory part no was unavailable.
https://m.summitracing.com/parts/maa-700
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Thu Apr 06, 2017 12:57 am
by trakkies
Ah. Misread the part that it was the original resistance wire. That could well have had a different value from the resistor Mallory recommend, so unless knowing for sure it was the same, I'd have bypassed it anyway.
Re: Engine intermittently dies - Logs show RUN: N
Posted: Mon Apr 24, 2017 11:34 am
by fordfanboi
No issues so far so it must have been that old resistance wire. Next I'll be installing the recommended ballast resistor and will see how that goes. If it fails again, I'll come back and post as such.